Loss and discovery

 


Some years ago I had enrolled for a course on Patanjali’s Yoga Sutra at the K.R. Cama Institute along with a friend. It was as my father accused me of, an excuse for having been a lazy non-practitioner trying to compensate by reading theory. I went through the weekly lectures diligently even as he went through hospitalization, cure, and ultimately passed away before I completed the course. He was a yoga practitioner and I have observed him with so much curiosity as a kid. Though he used to ask me sometime during my working years to learn yoga, he never made an attempt to teach me while I was much younger. Actually, being a Sri Vaishnava he didn’t teach me any of the traditional texts or slokas as well. It was not that he wasn’t interested, he just let us imbibe, read for ourselves, just assist us and kindle our curiosity even as we got busy with our own mundane existence of education, career, earning etc., I look at that as somewhat a reflection of what happens to a tradition, while some are memorized, committed to writing, propagated, some just remain a memory and wither away some day. As a community we have gone through this process. Loss and discovery. While some lost texts were re-discovered many were just lost. Some traditions stayed as a memory, and some faded.

Why am I reflecting on all this? One of those early days of International Yoga Day recognition and celebration I was doing a random search for Nathamuni’s ‘Yoga Rahasya’. The Sri Vaishnava Guru Parampara clearly states the first of the preceptors in the Sri Vaishnava tradition of Ramanuja sampradaya, Nathumani, was a Yogi and attributes the authorship of a text ‘Yoga Rahasya’ to him.  No fragments, no history of manuscripts, publication exist. To my surprise I found an edition of Nathamuni’s ‘Yoga Rahasya’ on the online retail platforms – that was a text which the renowned yoga guru Thirumalai Krishnamacharya had written and published after his death. Not being a student of Yoga, or a scholar, I had no idea of the works of Krishnamacharya and the status of the publications. Prodded by curiosity I went searching further for details and the contents of the book. I came across a blog that I am not able to trace now, nor recollect the name of the author that was highly skeptical of the story of rediscovery of ‘Yoga Rahasya’. I was engrossed in the story of its discovery.

Nathumani, the 9-10th century preceptor was the one who started the Sri Vaishnava parampara as it has come down over the last 1000 years with his re-discovery of the Nalayira Divya Prabandham, a compendium of the verses of the 12 Alvars. The discovery of Nalayria Divya Prabandham by Nathamuni is a well known legend among the Sri Vaishnavas – having heard just 10 verses out of over 1000 verses of Nammalvar’s Tirovaimozhi, his search for the rest, vision of Nammalvar and the gift of the entire corpus obtained through his Yogic vision. Without that discovery, the systematization of recitation of 4000, incorporating it into musical and dance recitations, propagation of it through a sishya parampara, the Sri Vaishnava sampradaya as it has come about through these centuries would not have been possible. It is believed that he taught Yoga to one of his students Kurugai Kavalappan which unfortunately didn’t get passed on through his grandson another illustrious guru of the parampara, Alavandar or Yamunacharya. While Alavandar has been instrumental in passing on the legacy and the Sri Vaishnava sampradaya which blossomed into a beautiful tradition and lives through to this day, the Yoga part of the Nathamuni’s legacy passed into oblivion. Nathamuni did the illustrious work of rediscovering the Prabandham for us, but unfortunately both his texts ‘Nyaya Tattva’ and ‘Yoga Rahasya’ were lost, and the yoga part in the whole sampradya context stayed on through Bhakti Yoga, Prapatti and Nityanushtanas but not the Yoga and Yogasana as such.

 

Centuries later a surprising rediscovery happened. At 16 Yoga Guru Krishnamacharya had a vision and walked all the way from Mysore to Alvar Tirunagari sometime in the early part of last century. Coming from the lineage of Nathamuni, Krishnamacharya saw the great preceptor in his vision and went searching for him to Alvar Tirunagari. At Alvar Tirungari just as Nathamuni found Nammalvar and through him received the entire 4000, Krishnamacharya said he met three people who looked like gurus and one of them was Nathamuni himself who instructed him on Yoga Rahasya.

“As we mature spiritually, we begin to understand that things happen for a reason. And we also recognize that there is often some divine intervention that supports us and our mission when we least expect it. When the Sri Vaishnava tradition was declining Nathamuni set out to revive it, he needed support to complete his task. Probably, this is why he received the Divya Prabandham.

Similarly, when yoga facing its dark days in the early twentieth century, Krishnamacharya needed support to fulfill his mission and preserve the tradition of yoga. This may be the reason for the divine intervention that allowed him to recover the lost teachings of the Yoga Rahasya, which would become such an invaluable tool in his work.” – This is what Kausthub Desikachar has written in his biography of Krishnamacharya ‘The Yoga of the Yogi’, about his coming to terms with the idea of discovery after a visit to Alvar Tirunagari.

I searched for information, and still trying to find a copy of the ‘Yoga Rahasya’ in translation that seems to be out print. Isn’t it such a surprise that the yoga that he popularized has had fans and students across the globe, yet his works aren’t popular are easily available. I found some blogs, some very interesting questions that are posed about the theory of discovery. One of them even said what else can a 16-year boy who walked 600 kilometers in intense heat encounter when he reached the destination, hinting at hallucination. I believe there are similar doubts about this other work, that he attributed a guru he met in the Himalayas.

“My father never acknowledged that he discovered anything even when I have seen that it was he who discovered. He has discovered postures but he would say that it was his teacher who taught him. Rarely has he said that it was his “original” work. At the same time, I have seen him – because I am his son also composing some verses and correcting those verses for the Chandas (Metre) and all that and finally saying – this is what Nathamuni is saying and this is what my teacher says! I tend to think that the Nathamuni’s Yoga Rahasya that he taught us is quite likely to be a combination of his own commentary and the lessons he received though he would not accept it.”

– ‘The Study of Yoga Rahasya‘ – Extract from an Interview with TKV Desikachar in KYM DarÅ›anam, a publication from Krishnamacharya Yoga Mandiram vol 1 no 1 Feb 1991: Source: internet


Krishnamacharya’s mission and his texts seem to have given rise to doubt about the antiquity of yogic practices when it comes to the asanas prevalent now, the “popular yoga” being differentiated from The Yoga as a darsana, Patanjali and the tradition of yore. They arise from lack of clear documentation from the side of the guru, publishing the texts and laying out claims clearly, or what else, I do not know.  But, with various schools from across the country, the global phenomenon that yoga has become, and the denial of its Indian origin, the denial of it being Hindu, makes it essential to read our modern masters and document their work. To me the story of a descendent of Nathamuni retrace a similar path to discover one of his texts is fascinating. May be totally unacceptable to modern mind, but the loss and discovery has been part of the tradition. To understand the loss and trace the discovery, what a scintillating study it would be for any sadhaka. Will wait for a day when such sadhakas emerge and we have a clear and modern view of yoga as it has emerged in the last hundred years.   

 Reference:

http://www.sutrajournal.com/krishnamacharyas-yoga-rahasya-by-eric-shaw

https://www.yogajournal.com/yoga-101/krishnamacharya-s-legacy/

https://www.exoticindiaart.com/book/details/yoga-rahasya-of-nathamuni-NAH808/

Photos: From the internet

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Elegant temple and the exotic maidens

Shyaamalaam Saralaam Susmitaam Bhuushitaam